2008
Jacqueline Honulik
2007
Melanie Mudry
2006 Jeannine Phillips
2005 Melissa Mandak
2004 Sheila Wiatr
2003 Michelle LaFrance
2002 Alita Dawson - 4th
Runner-Up
2001 Amy Vanderoef
2000 Sallie Toussaint
1999 Christina D1Amico
1998 Kristina Hughes
1997 Christine Pavone
1996 Wanda Gonzalez
1995 Traci Bryant
1994 Mistrella Egan
1993 Alison Benusis
1992 Catherine Sanchez
1991 Valorie Abate
1990 Allison Barbeau-Diorio
1989 Lisa C. Vendetti
1988 Cathy Galasso
1987 Jolene Foy
1986 Jennifer Benusis
1985 Adrianne Hazelwood
1984 Lynne Scalo
1983 Mary Lynn Seleman
1982 Maureen Szekeres
1981 Kelly Thompson
1980 Kristine Wilson
1979 Mary Beth Lombardi
1978 Martha Szabo
1977 Sue Crone
1976 Rozalyn Ralph
1975 Michele Menegay
1974 Valerie Cappello
1973 Wendy Vecchiarino
1972 Diane Stevens
1971 Diane Turetsky
1970 Patricia Matthews
1969 Elizabeth Wanderman
- Semifinalist
1968 Janice Shilinsky -
Semifinalist
1967 Linda Drews
1966 Pat Denne - 1st Runner-Up
1965 Elizabeth Matusko
1964 Patricia Powell
1963 Gail Dinan
1962 Diana Zabicki - 1st
Runner-Up
1961 Florence Mayette -
Semifinalist
1960 Joyce Trautwig - Semifinalist
1959 Jayne Burghardt
1958 Dorothy Dillen
1957 Rosemary Galliotti
1956 Dorothy Bailey
1955 Jane Bartolotta
1954 Andrea Todd - Semifinalist
1953 Beverlee Burlant
1952 Jo Kuhlmann
